Thought I'd drop an update on the experience after taking out a 1 yr old Swan OB for the long weekend.
Impressions of the pop-top experience:
- Wife and kids completely in love with it (sigh).
- Definitely easier (on me) to set up. Not hugely faster, but easier ... no pulling canvas and hauling stuff out of the trailer in to the tent.
- For overnighters, it's DEFINITELY a better option, just throw your bags and bedding on the lounge or floor and close the lid ... no hauling stuff in and out of the trailer / car
- To be honest, the biggest difference was not the speed of set-but rather the different experience, with the comfortable interior and features.
Impressions of the Swan itself:
- Towed and braked beautifully. Had a Trigg hitch which was amazing, no feedback from the trailer at all vs. a bit of knocking from the softfloor which runs on a standard towball.
- Width was a bit unexpected. With the softfloor, if the Prado is in the lane, so is the softfloor ... that's not the case with the Swan which is considerably wider than the Prado.
- Surprised at the build quality. Plastic catch on the water filler cover kept popping off, main bed plywood base was noticeably starting to sag in the middle, several cupboard latches would stick shut, some of the screws on the outside of the unit had started to rust ... this on a 1 yr old unit!
- Water pumps and on-board hot water were VERY nice features
- Had a factory 100Ah battery with solar panel, yet we managed to drain the battery by night #2 just through lights, water pumps and iPad charging (fridge was on gas). Would want to upgrade the panels and / or the Setec battery management system if I got one.
- Managed to run out of water but I suspect I just didn't fill them properly, I stopped filling when the water started gurgling out but I must have been using too much water pressure. It was a dual tank unit so I can't believe we actually used two tanks in two days!
Conclusion:
- For touring I would choose the pop-top hands-down. It's also more comfortable if it's cold, and features like pumps and hot water are obviously nice.
- For 'destination' camping I would choose a soft-floor for the room and outdoor space, especially in summer.
- I would happily hire a Jayco again, but would be wary about buying one.
We've decided to stick with the soft-floor. But if a nice Goldstream came along at the right price, who knows ... !
Cheers