Who really cares?
The 4WDOTY award doesn't go to the tuffest, most capable offroad, most reliable, cheapest spare parts, most available 4WD accessories etc etc.
The award goes to a 4WD vehicle that is affordable, has lots of bling accessories and is fairly popular. Guess what, Jeep wins. Like them or loath them, they are selling 5hedloads in Australia.
I take as much notice of this award as I do for Car of the Year, Camper Trailer of the year etc.
Me, I don't like Jeeps and I would never own one but I can't argue with them winning this award.