Author Topic: Which Tow Vehicle to buy?  (Read 9792 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline molongmick

  • Sleeping Bag User
  • *
  • Posts: 27
  • Gender: Male
  • Jayco Expanda
Which Tow Vehicle to buy?
« on: June 03, 2012, 12:00:19 PM »
Okay, I've been looking at a few duel cab utes over the past few weeks and I am having some difficulty in deciding which ute to buy.
 
Originally the BT-50 was at the top of the list, but I took the Navara ST for a drive yesterday and was very surprised with the vehicle.
 
The Triton is out as the back seat is no good, Have a bad atste with the Isuszu/Holden D-Max/Rodeo, Ford Ranger is $5k more than the BT-50, Amorak is nice, but limited wth 2.8 towing capacity.
 
So the two cars I'm down to
 
Navara ST:
 $43 000 drive away
 140kw 450nm
 3t towing 300kg down ball
 
BT-50: XTR (lots of little nicities, not necessities)
 Bigger car, but $50 000 price tag
 147kw 470nm
 3.3t towing 330kg down ball
 

Both cars will be kitted out with identical gear for most part, so that cost will not change dramaticially, apart from the delay in getting a canopy for the BT-50, as they don't have them in stock.
 
Extras will include:
 Redarc brake controller
 Tub Liner
 Canopy, high line with roof racks (150kg limit), three lift up windows
 T13, TJM bar with 9000lb synthetic tjm winch
 towbar and wiring
 lightforce driving lights
 snorkle
 battery isolator
 battery outlet/connection in tub
 transplanted icom 440 uhf radio
 
Will be towing a 2.5t van

My question is,
 
If you had a choice, and yes money will be an issue and probably deciding factor, which of these two would you buy?
 
Please tell me of any experience with either.

I would like to know of fuel consuption, real life, not quotes figures from books. This will also play an important roll in the decision.
Cheers Mick

2010 GU7 Patrol
Jayco Expanda 17.56-2OutBack

Offline Jason B

  • "Mark Goldie recovery team coordinator"
  • Hard Top Camper User
  • ******
  • Posts: 2880
  • Thanked: 45 times
  • Gender: Male
  • 80 Series Turbo DX Cruiser, Kimberley Kamper 2013 SE
Re: Which Tow Vehicle to buy?
« Reply #1 on: June 03, 2012, 12:18:17 PM »
My two bobs worth.

A mate at work has just bought a BT-50 TD and I have had the opportunity to take it for a drive. It is an impressive vehicle rides nice and would be a comfortable place to spend many hours. It has heaps of power and is bloody big when you get up close to it.

Another mate has a Navara STR (I think?) which is about 2 years old (so I am not sure if its changed body/power etc in that time and is different to the one you are looking at). He has had a few niggling issues with it, but largley it has been a good vehicle and he is happy with it.

To me thay are chalk and cheese. The Navara is a duel cab ute and feels like a duel cab ute to drive. Its also much small than the BT. The BT on the other hand is much more comfortable and would double as a comfy family car, not to mention it is much bigger and would suit my family better.

Both vehicles will do the job you want them to, it is probably a bit early in the BT50's life to see what retained values will be like to make and decisions regarding the extra purchase price.

If it was my money today after spending some time in both of these I would go for the BT50, because I know once the price has been forgotton it would be the vehicle I was most happy with.

Also after having first hand dealing with Nissan (manly with 3.0lt patrols) they are a PITA to deal with and will squirm out any warranty issue that can. (I dont have any first hand dealings with Mazda to campare).

So for me it would be the BT50.

Regards


Jas

Offline D4D

  • Hard Top Camper User
  • ******
  • Posts: 16019
  • Thanked: 391 times
  • Are we there yet?
Re: Which Tow Vehicle to buy?
« Reply #2 on: June 03, 2012, 12:21:26 PM »
If you plan to do any sort of off road towing/touring I'd be looking at something other than a dual cab ute. I don't think the rear chassis and tow bar is up to it. Lots of reports of load 'em up and they banana. Sure they can tow 3T but that's on the black top occasionally not 1000 klms of corrugations in a day.
I owe, I owe, it’s off to work I go…

Work - Outback
Play - Prado

Offline Mrs smith

  • Soft Floor Camper User
  • ****
  • Posts: 331
  • Thanked: 2 times
Re: Which Tow Vehicle to buy?
« Reply #3 on: June 03, 2012, 01:03:16 PM »
Any Mazda dealers in Alice Springs ? Just something to consider.
The  Navara's had a tall first gear, not sure if it's been changed.
IMO
Mazda's have always suffered with resale prices as they age.   

Offline Jason B

  • "Mark Goldie recovery team coordinator"
  • Hard Top Camper User
  • ******
  • Posts: 2880
  • Thanked: 45 times
  • Gender: Male
  • 80 Series Turbo DX Cruiser, Kimberley Kamper 2013 SE
Re: Which Tow Vehicle to buy?
« Reply #4 on: June 03, 2012, 01:46:28 PM »
If you plan to do any sort of off road towing/touring I'd be looking at something other than a dual cab ute. I don't think the rear chassis and tow bar is up to it. Lots of reports of load 'em up and they banana. Sure they can tow 3T but that's on the black top occasionally not 1000 klms of corrugations in a day.

Very true and this needs to be considered when purchasing as there are some pretty bad photos out there. However I think Mazda/Ford have increased the chassis size in response to some issues.

Any vehicle you buy will have issues, plenty of D4D motors dropping injectors etc out there now, the new 200's don't tolerate bad fuel with horrendous repair bills being reported, starter motors and alternators being killed in river crossings etc. So even the big $$$ flash rigs that every one seems to aspire to have there issues when pushed out side of their comfort zones.

There are horror stories with any model if you go lookling for them.

I envy your position mate and wish it was me looking for a new rig, there are lots of good ones out there to chose from. At the end of the day go with the one that suits your needs the best.


regards

Jas

Offline D4D

  • Hard Top Camper User
  • ******
  • Posts: 16019
  • Thanked: 391 times
  • Are we there yet?
Re: Which Tow Vehicle to buy?
« Reply #5 on: June 03, 2012, 01:50:37 PM »
plenty of D4D motors dropping injectors etc out there now

You're ripping my heart out :)

Actually looks like it is the injector seals.
I owe, I owe, it’s off to work I go…

Work - Outback
Play - Prado

Offline Jason B

  • "Mark Goldie recovery team coordinator"
  • Hard Top Camper User
  • ******
  • Posts: 2880
  • Thanked: 45 times
  • Gender: Male
  • 80 Series Turbo DX Cruiser, Kimberley Kamper 2013 SE
Re: Which Tow Vehicle to buy?
« Reply #6 on: June 03, 2012, 02:22:22 PM »
You're ripping my heart out :)

Actually looks like it is the injector seals.

I believe so mate, apparently some service bulitens in NZ are recommending that the seals are replaced during service every 45000km. I don't believe this has been adopted in Aus yet. Still one of the best vehicles out though (120 series)

Regards

Jas

Offline molongmick

  • Sleeping Bag User
  • *
  • Posts: 27
  • Gender: Male
  • Jayco Expanda
Re: Which Tow Vehicle to buy?
« Reply #7 on: June 03, 2012, 02:25:29 PM »
Gee Whizz, you guys have given me something to think about.

My current patrol is as thirtsy as and does not have the storage need for my trips, which is why I am migrating from a "Big" 4x4 to a duel cab, plus most of my off road driving is not what you would call EXTREME.

There is not much out there on the WWW regarding the BT50 engine, from what I have  worked out the engine originated from Landrover, then migrated to the Ford transit van then into the Ranger/BT50, correct me if I'm wrong.

The D40 Narava engine has been reworked and is not the standard clunker of the older Navara's.

When I tow the van it will be our destination, which will be used as a base, then doing day trips, as I don't even think the Patrol could tow it into some locations.

All I know is that I wont buy another patrol, very disoppointed with it's towing ability and economy while towing.

I have only looked at the figures of the Hilux, but feel that the 2.5 tow limit is too close for comfort for me.
Cheers Mick

2010 GU7 Patrol
Jayco Expanda 17.56-2OutBack

Offline Mace

  • Hard Top Camper User
  • ******
  • Posts: 3678
  • Thanked: 142 times
  • Gender: Male
  • Life's to short to drive a boring vehicle.
Re: Which Tow Vehicle to buy?
« Reply #8 on: June 03, 2012, 02:28:10 PM »
Neither.

I know they are rated to 3 tonne plus, but I agree with D4D.

Ive said it before, so, for the sake of consistency on my behalf, and Ill say it again.
 
IMO if your towing 2500kg, get a Landcruiser.

Ill shut up now.!   ;D

 :cheers:
2009 Jeep Grand Cherokee Diesel
2009 Coromal 452
2002 Commodore SS (The Toy)

Offline Fun Police

  • Soft Floor Camper User
  • ****
  • Posts: 481
  • Thanked: 2 times
  • Gender: Male
Which Tow Vehicle to buy?
« Reply #9 on: June 03, 2012, 02:54:12 PM »
Just curious...why did you say the tritons back seat is no good??

The extra leg room, and comfort was a big seller for me. Is it the curved arches that puts you off??
You can't spell 'funeral' without 'fun', nor 'manslaughter' without 'laughter'

Offline molongmick

  • Sleeping Bag User
  • *
  • Posts: 27
  • Gender: Male
  • Jayco Expanda
Re: Which Tow Vehicle to buy?
« Reply #10 on: June 03, 2012, 03:03:37 PM »
With three kids sitting in the back, the centre seat position really pushes you forward. I only really noticed this when I sat in there myself and thought it rather uncomfortable.

Don't worry, originally it was near the top of my list, I was very close to buying the triton.
Cheers Mick

2010 GU7 Patrol
Jayco Expanda 17.56-2OutBack

Offline Jason B

  • "Mark Goldie recovery team coordinator"
  • Hard Top Camper User
  • ******
  • Posts: 2880
  • Thanked: 45 times
  • Gender: Male
  • 80 Series Turbo DX Cruiser, Kimberley Kamper 2013 SE
Re: Which Tow Vehicle to buy?
« Reply #11 on: June 03, 2012, 03:22:52 PM »
With regards to the towing ability.

I agree with D4D and Mace. I work for the Government and we need to tow boats and use our vehicles in off road conditions. We also use them at their upper load carrying ability all of the time. Our fleet has slowly changed from Patrols and Landcruisers to, Hiluxes, tritons, Dmaxs etc. However cracks are now starting to appear in this cost saving approach.

After weighing a number of these vehicles as used they don't comply with front or read axle weights (some GVM). Also we have been doing diffs, clutches and gear boxes in the 3 years that we keep them (60-80k km). I noticed that the last vehicle we had replaced (a hilux) which frequently tows a 3t boat was replaced with a TDV8 cruiser.

With regard to warranty, essentially we have none. The manufacturers basically claim we are using them beyond there design limits. Essentially yes they can tow 3T but are not designed to do it daily, and especially off road in demanding conditions. This is very similar use to using one for touring when you think about it.

There are currently a lot of negotiations going on to try and sort out warranty, and axle load issues with manufacturers.

Without doubt the first thing I would look at when buying a new vehicle would be, can the GVM be upgraded?? Most of the time this needs to be done prior to it being first registered. But if you are serious about touring and when it all turns to sh!t, to me the piece of mind of knowing that I was legal and covered by insurance is worth far more than the 3k for a GVM upgrade.

In my opinion the new 200 series isn't worth a look with its factory load carrying capacity. Unless the GVM had been upgraded their wouldn't be one loaded up with a family, roof rack, winch, bar, draws, spare wheel carrier, water tank, long range tank etc that would be legal. Most will get a way with it. But if it did turn to sh!t and someone was seriously injured (your fault or not) or killed you will be on your own.

Speaking the the RTA inspectors recently when I got our workmate V8TD weighed confirmed this. They indicated basically that they were not interested in vehicles under 4t (4.5 maybe) HOWEVER if there was a fatal or serious accident and the police asked for an expert witness, then they do investigate and you would be screwed once the issues were identified.

They concede that 99% of the passenger vehicles towing caravans around the country at the moment would be overloaded and illegal, either GVM or axle loads, trailer weights, overall weights etc. They just don't want to know about it...............................................................................................YET.


Regards

Jas

« Last Edit: June 03, 2012, 04:23:12 PM by Jason B »

Offline D4D

  • Hard Top Camper User
  • ******
  • Posts: 16019
  • Thanked: 391 times
  • Are we there yet?
Re: Which Tow Vehicle to buy?
« Reply #12 on: June 03, 2012, 04:14:22 PM »
They concede that 99% of the passenger vehicles towing caravans around the country at the moment would be overloaded and illegal, either GVM or axle loads, trailer weights, overall weights etc.

As much as the Bushtracker caravan guy is a tosser he is right in saying to pull the weight of gear people now want in their vans you need an F250 or similar...
I owe, I owe, it’s off to work I go…

Work - Outback
Play - Prado

Offline dno

  • Hard Top Camper User
  • ******
  • Posts: 1865
  • Thanked: 3 times
  • Welcome to gods country
"The first half of our lives are ruined by our parents  and the second half by our children."

                      Clarence Day

     http://www.youtube.com/user/67dno/videos

Offline Jon

  • Hard Floor Camper User
  • *****
  • Posts: 1142
  • Thanked: 7 times
  • Gender: Male
  • Bringing rain to every campsite
Re: Which Tow Vehicle to buy?
« Reply #14 on: June 03, 2012, 05:08:04 PM »
110 dual cab Defender?
I got a sweater for Xmas, really wanted a moaner or screamer.

Offline rocket327s

  • Tent User
  • ***
  • Posts: 166
  • Gender: Male
Re: Which Tow Vehicle to buy?
« Reply #15 on: June 03, 2012, 05:32:27 PM »
i LUV my 2010 Navara D40..... but i will admit although I have pulled a caravan with it I have not done any extreme or near extreme offroad.
The only gripe i have is the cost of Nissan services. but i guess all dealers charge similar prices.
After some pretty bad experiences with my previous XTrail (serviced by independent mechanics) I decided to stay with nissan & cop the high prices in favour of warranty......which IF necessary I will fight for tooth & nail...
I looked at Maxda, Holden & Toyota & happily settled for the Navara
Jayco Starcraft Outback
Nissan Navara D40

Offline Big Nath

  • "hows ya bum for grubs"
  • Hard Floor Camper User
  • *****
  • Posts: 771
  • Gender: Male
NAKED 2012 Pathfinder ST in Auto, Scan Guage, Polyair Airbags, 80CH Uniden UHF, Leisure Matters Camper!

Offline mrdenn1s

  • Soft Floor Camper User
  • ****
  • Posts: 610
  • Thanked: 33 times
  • Gender: Male
    • Dennis Does Cricket
Re: Which Tow Vehicle to buy?
« Reply #17 on: June 03, 2012, 06:09:57 PM »
navara has much lower clearance than the BT-50...if going off road, please take into consideration

Also, BT50 has 5 yr warranty vs 3.......
2014 Blue Water Tanami Soft floor Camper
2000 Landcruiser 105 GXL Inline 6
2011 Kia Sorento

Offline Mace

  • Hard Top Camper User
  • ******
  • Posts: 3678
  • Thanked: 142 times
  • Gender: Male
  • Life's to short to drive a boring vehicle.
Re: Which Tow Vehicle to buy?
« Reply #18 on: June 03, 2012, 06:13:50 PM »
My main issue is the D40 is 500kg (unladen) lighter than the Caravan.

A patrol or Cruiser are at least as heavy as the Van  (2500/2650 kg) in their bare form.

Basic laws of physics and pendulum forces if things go wrong are my concern.

I cringe every time I pass a D40 on the highway going the other way with a large dual axle van on the back, and sigh when its safely passed.  They have become the vehicle of choice for many towing this type of van because of their lower cost.  Im sure theyre a great vehicle, but IMO not suitable for this type of towing.

 :cheers:
2009 Jeep Grand Cherokee Diesel
2009 Coromal 452
2002 Commodore SS (The Toy)

Offline D4D

  • Hard Top Camper User
  • ******
  • Posts: 16019
  • Thanked: 391 times
  • Are we there yet?
Re: Which Tow Vehicle to buy?
« Reply #19 on: June 03, 2012, 06:19:11 PM »
I cringe every time I pass a D40 on the highway going the other way with a large dual axle van on the back

Same here and they're the rigs with weight distribution hitches which put even more stress on the chassis/towbar.
I owe, I owe, it’s off to work I go…

Work - Outback
Play - Prado

Offline Jason B

  • "Mark Goldie recovery team coordinator"
  • Hard Top Camper User
  • ******
  • Posts: 2880
  • Thanked: 45 times
  • Gender: Male
  • 80 Series Turbo DX Cruiser, Kimberley Kamper 2013 SE
Re: Which Tow Vehicle to buy?
« Reply #20 on: June 03, 2012, 06:20:20 PM »
Any reason you have ruled the Hilux out? 

http://www.discountnewcars.com.au/toyota/toyota-hilux-kun26r-workmate-utility-double-cab-4dr-4x4-3-0dt-toyo12dw.aspx


Cost?, old engine design, and Cost I reckon. The others have not only caught up with but are currently eclipsing the Hilux I think. Toyota will strike back, eventually.

Offline rocket327s

  • Tent User
  • ***
  • Posts: 166
  • Gender: Male
Re: Which Tow Vehicle to buy?
« Reply #21 on: June 03, 2012, 06:24:19 PM »
I DID say i haven't done extreme off road........ am waiting for a 2012 Dove Outback to be delivered & doubt even then i will do EXTREME....
As far as the towbar is concerned I was advised at time of purchase (by the dealer) that i should avoid the Nissan towbar because of the chassis fracture issue. I went with the Hayman Reese
Jayco Starcraft Outback
Nissan Navara D40

Offline fuji

  • "Tail End Charlie"
  • Hard Top Camper User
  • ******
  • Posts: 2796
  • Thanked: 28 times
  • Gender: Male
  • "nolle timere" Don't be afraid
Re: Which Tow Vehicle to buy?
« Reply #22 on: June 03, 2012, 06:34:14 PM »
Neither.

I know they are rated to 3 tonne plus, but I agree with D4D.

Ive said it before, so, for the sake of consistency on my behalf, and Ill say it again.
 
IMO if your towing 2500kg, get a Landcruiser.

Ill shut up now.!   ;D

 :cheers:




Thats why I bought a Landcruiser Workmate. I really liked the BT-50 when I bought my Mazda 3. Nearly bought one. :angel:
2017 (79 series) Landcruiser, and Evernew E100😎

Offline Silvo

  • Hard Top Camper User
  • ******
  • Posts: 2646
  • Thanked: 16 times
  • Gender: Male
  • The grass is greener where you water it..
Re: Which Tow Vehicle to buy?
« Reply #23 on: June 03, 2012, 06:45:31 PM »
having owned a D40, I honestly believe that it would die trying to tow my Complete Campsite at 1.8T let alone your van at 2.5T.

i personally wouldn't buy a ute again. I went into the Prado and haven't really looked back. the wagons are HEAPS more comfortable to tour in over the utes. i can drive for 12 hours towing, and get out of the prado and keep doing stuff. When i was doing the same thing in the D40 - i was a write off after a long drive.

i can fit everything in from the utw to the wagon, and i dare say if you can't, that you are carrying too much. Just my opinions.

between the two, i would choose the BT50.

Dan
Dan - 2015 Discovery 4 SDV6 HSE and Lifestyle Camper AT10 EVO

Offline Mace

  • Hard Top Camper User
  • ******
  • Posts: 3678
  • Thanked: 142 times
  • Gender: Male
  • Life's to short to drive a boring vehicle.
Re: Which Tow Vehicle to buy?
« Reply #24 on: June 03, 2012, 06:45:56 PM »
am waiting for a 2012 Dove Outback to be delivered & doubt even then i will do EXTREME....

I think a D40 is a perfect vehicle for you.

 :cheers:
2009 Jeep Grand Cherokee Diesel
2009 Coromal 452
2002 Commodore SS (The Toy)