They were a close contender when I got the ProComps, I really liked the tread pattern and heard good reports coming from the commercial sector (telstra, mining and some earthmoving service guys) who were using them more than rec guys.
The only reason I went ProComps in the end was I got a deal to good to refuse saving $65 a corner and I was also in need of 6 so it was a huge saving for me. I have seen some Goodyear dealers advertising 4 for the price of 3 ATM so that would be a good deal on what seems a good tyre.