I was looking for a good all round tyre for the 200 when we took delivery back in March.
We too had the ATZ 4 rib and were very happy with them, and we have also had the Cooper ST Maxx, which again we were happy with - and both of these we had on our Pajero. When it came to the 200, I figured that we do 80% on the tarmac to get to the 20% off road, and the P3 and ST Maxx were just that little too aggressive.
We went with the Bridgestone Dueler D697 AT and we have been extremely impressed with them. We have had one puncture, but that was from a spike on the Old Ghan Railway Line which any tyre would have had the same result as I wasn't paying attention, ran over it and it flicked up from the front tyre and straight into the rear tyre which puctured.
On road they have great manners and are not noisy, and offroad they have been equally as good. They were also cheaper than the other two options too!
Brand: Bridgestone Dueler D697
Type: AT
Size: 285/70/17
Expected Milage: No idea but lots
Cost: $353ea
Dealer: City Discount Tyres in Adelaide