Hi ya
I have had several types. One ARB for my Prado and it was great, hardly any wind noise. Made of steel. Did the Simpson easy. The second, was rhino roof racks with cage. Okay but never used for serious stuff. The third is a Windcheetah from Opposite Lock. I highly recommend this one although it is flat and has no sides. . Did the Kimberleys and 20k of sealed and unsealed. Camewith a ladder.
Wayne