MySwag.org The Off-road Camper Trailer Forum

General => General Discussion => Topic started by: UTE 701 on December 30, 2011, 04:19:46 PM

Title: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: UTE 701 on December 30, 2011, 04:19:46 PM
I saw in a Farmer Direct magazine :  Snake Repellers ....

( Pardon me if this has been talked about before . )

Has anyone tried these ?

Do they work ?

Seem perfect for taking camping if they work .

( and I'm not talking to the women about taking one to bed !  :laugh:)

Two companies have them : oakent and envirobug

And they have some good looking mozzie catchers too .

Anyway , here's what they look like .....

(http://i962.photobucket.com/albums/ae110/shootnrun_photos/My%20Swag%20Misc/snakeoakent.jpg)   (http://i962.photobucket.com/albums/ae110/shootnrun_photos/My%20Swag%20Misc/snakeenvirobug.jpg)
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: JethroT on December 30, 2011, 04:23:30 PM
No
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: dno on December 30, 2011, 04:35:02 PM
Was on another forum the other day and someone had similar solar jobbies in the yard along with ole mate joe- blake, so i'm going to say NO.. they don't work.
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: Mandrake on December 30, 2011, 04:46:58 PM
Only sure snake repellant I know of is a blue-tongue lizard !!

Cheers

Steve
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: jeeps on December 30, 2011, 05:05:38 PM
Canetoads are great. The more cane toads you have around the less snakes. Sorry but it's true.

Cheers
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: D4D on December 30, 2011, 05:07:16 PM
Only sure snake repellant I know of is a blue-tongue lizard !!

I thought that too until I had what I thought was a tiger in the yard. Spoke to the shire snake dude who happened to be the head reptile dude at the zoo and he said that was an old wives tale.
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: Symon on December 30, 2011, 05:21:48 PM
As far as I know the best snake repellent is noise, they hate it as it disrupts their hunting.
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: Mandrake on December 30, 2011, 05:26:42 PM
Not noise - coz they are deaf - no ears even - Its vibrations they sense ..
Steve
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: Tim - Stratford on December 30, 2011, 05:43:04 PM
I thought that too until I had what I thought was a tiger in the yard. Spoke to the shire snake dude who happened to be the head reptile dude at the zoo and he said that was an old wives tale.

Same here - until the family of Blue tongues we hand feed let a copperhead into the yard...the hound got it though.

I've heard that snake repellent works best in NZ  ;D
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: D4D on December 30, 2011, 05:44:08 PM
I've heard that snake repellent works best in NZ  ;D

Snake or sheep?
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: RedProw on December 30, 2011, 06:17:32 PM
Well I would have to disagree with the vast majority. I think that there is some merit to them.

We are currently living in a shed whilst we are waiting for our house to be built (it has been a long wait). We had seen quite a number of snakes around the place, manly blacks last year. The wife had the unfortunate surprise of walking into the bathroom part of our shed to be greeted by a black snake. As far as she was concerned, the living in the shed experience was over and she wanted to rent a house while we are waiting for our own place to be built. Unfortunately renting a place was not part of the plan (the theory that the rent we would have paid, pays for the shed).

So I became gullable. I looked into the snake repellers and decided to get a couple. It was the only way to keep the wife happy. We have had the repellers operating for about twelve months. Although I initially put them in towards the end of the 'snake' season last year, I didn't see any snakes after I installed them. So far this year all the neighbours have had multiple snakes around their homes, I am happy to say (touch wood) that we have not seen a single snake to date.

The theory is that the units send vibrations through the ground similar to that generated by livestock. The snakes are supposedly able to identify that the vibration is a 'dangerous' one and keep clear. Obviously it is still important to remain vigilant, however whilst everyone around us have encountered snakes we have not.......do they work.......jury is still out, if we go through the entire season without seeing a single snake I will probably purchase a couple more to put around the house when it is finally finished.

Proof will be in the pudding  ;D
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: D4D on December 30, 2011, 06:40:04 PM
Make sure you let us know how they go RedProw. I might get some just to keep the missus happy too, placebo effect :)
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: barneys on December 30, 2011, 07:08:40 PM
there was a story on snakes on bush telegraphy  on radio national  to day  between 11 am and 12  . they  had a bit on how to keep snakes out of your way worth a listen. you can pod it
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: griz066 on December 30, 2011, 07:15:20 PM
repeller scam (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sS6J-ifUrKA#ws)

SCAM Perhaps.
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: heath74 on December 30, 2011, 07:25:47 PM
hmm thats not too promising...

I wonder if a wild snake would behave the same as a tame snake?  I mean a wild snake would take off if you got that close to it, (apart from a brown maybe) I wonder if just as the tame snake is desensitised to human contact, perhaps the man made sounds the snake repeller makes also dont bother the tame snake.

Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: RedProw on December 30, 2011, 08:09:33 PM
Interesting watching that video, the snake probably didn't move because the repeller didn't go off, it would be quite audible on the video.  Ours is very similar to the one shown and cycles approx every 5 minutes, and it changes its cycle every week from single to multiple beeps, it is does not give out a constant vibration. When we first got them I thought I would have to send them back because I could hear them going off from inside the shed throughout the night. Now I don't take any notice of the noise.........and the misus is sleeping better  ;D. However I don't assume that it is 100% effective. It will be interesting to see how it continues to perfrom over the coming months. I will provide an update to those who may be interested  :angel:
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: GLC on December 31, 2011, 08:34:28 AM
hmm thats not too promising...

I wonder if a wild snake would behave the same as a tame snake?  I mean a wild snake would take off if you got that close to it, (apart from a brown maybe) I wonder if just as the tame snake is desensitised to human contact, perhaps the man made sounds the snake repeller makes also dont bother the tame snake.
Heath I am with you, the snake has built up a relationship with the handler of trust so recognises that the handler is not going to put it in harms way.  same way good snake handlers do at snake shows, the snake keeps referring back to the handler to see what they should do, handler relaxed snake is relaxed.  He also had to acclimatise the snake to the repeller and only lets go of the snake once acclimatised.
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: Maîneÿ . . . on December 31, 2011, 09:24:50 AM
tis funny what you don't see when using a video camera  :-[
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: Blinky Bill on December 31, 2011, 09:31:14 AM
That was one well fed contented looking snake.   ;D With an attitude more like a pussy cat high on marijuana, it could get expelled from the Tiger Club.  ???

We have a resident red belly black that lives down in our vegie garden (keeps an eye on visitors to our compost heap). I've been informed by the local snake expert that if you're going to have a snake around the place then the red belly black is good value as they keep away browns. Blacks are not aggressive, will hiss if annoyed, next will feint a strike, next strike without injecting if further annoyed and finally will inject if they have no choice.

Having said all of that we treat it with the utmost respect and just leave it alone. Same goes for Monty our resident python. Though at times I do grab Monty and relocate him if he's heading towards something dangerous like the tractor slasher.   ???

But yeah I've never heard of these gadgets before.

Cheers & beers for New Years  :cheers: - Wayne
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: jeeps on December 31, 2011, 09:48:45 AM
4 years ago during a big wet about this time of year we had an explosion of green tree frogs. They were everywhere, thicker than flies:

(http://i421.photobucket.com/albums/pp300/jeeps_photo/Home/frogs6.jpg)

(http://i421.photobucket.com/albums/pp300/jeeps_photo/Home/frogs2.jpg)

(http://i421.photobucket.com/albums/pp300/jeeps_photo/Home/frogs3.jpg)

The next 12 months we had snakes everywhere, a few greenies in the house and 10+ big brownies killed by the dogs. The next 2 years were similar, plenty of brown snakes around almost daily but no green frogs for years. In the past 12 months i don't think we've seen a snake at all but there's lots and lots of cane toads around which there never were before.

The last couple of weeks we're getting a few green tree frogs hanging around again. Looks like next year is a snake year for us.

I also think that my electric fence tends to keep them away too, but i don't have it on very often.

cheers
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: jaycamrie on December 31, 2011, 12:07:24 PM
That was one well fed contented looking snake.   ;D With an attitude more like a pussy cat high on marijuana, it could get expelled from the Tiger Club.  ???

We have a resident red belly black that lives down in our vegie garden (keeps an eye on visitors to our compost heap). I've been informed by the local snake expert that if you're going to have a snake around the place then the red belly black is good value as they keep away browns. Blacks are not aggressive, will hiss if annoyed, next will feint a strike, next strike without injecting if further annoyed and finally will inject if they have no choice.

Having said all of that we treat it with the utmost respect and just leave it alone. Same goes for Monty our resident python. Though at times I do grab Monty and relocate him if he's heading towards something dangerous like the tractor slasher.   ???

But yeah I've never heard of these gadgets before.

Cheers & beers for New Years  :cheers: - Wayne
We have quite a few blacks and browns around the farm and i agree would rather have all blacks they are pretty non agressive and would rather run away then stick around,  browns a different kettle of fish though they are a lot more inquisitive.
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: UTE 701 on December 31, 2011, 12:36:20 PM
I also think that my electric fence tends to keep them away too, but i don't have it on very often.
cheers

I wonder if the electric fence is along the same lines as the pulses being picked up by the snake , rather than making contact ??
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: jeeps on December 31, 2011, 02:57:58 PM
I wonder if the electric fence is along the same lines as the pulses being picked up by the snake , rather than making contact ??

I've got plenty of grass and branches touching my electric tape causing an earth short so it clicks and carries on. It's not detrimental to the system, it just reduces the amount of voltage further down the fence but every little weed/blade of grass that earths the tape creates a vibration that they certainly would feel as some of those clicks can be very loud. As long as you aren't too strict about making sure the tape is completely isolated and click free it works well ;)


cheers
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: fishfinder on January 04, 2012, 06:10:19 PM
i know a snake repellent that works and have witnessed the snake backing rite away did not want a bar of it - most supermarkets and chemists sells them
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: bobnrob on January 05, 2012, 09:18:09 AM
i know a snake repellent that works and have witnessed the snake backing rite away did not want a bar of it - most supermarkets and chemists sells them

And is ???
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: griz066 on January 05, 2012, 11:52:23 AM
Dunno??????

http://www.liquidfence.com/snake-repellents.html (http://www.liquidfence.com/snake-repellents.html)
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: RedProw on May 29, 2012, 10:40:26 PM
Well for those that are interested.........we went the entire snake season without a single snake. All our neighbours had snake encounters this season. I am slowly turning from skeptic to believer. Friends of ours had a real snake issue this year and were averaging a snake a week around the house until they also installed a couple of these repellers. From the installation until now not a single snake.

Still ever cautious but as far as I am concerned these things may have some merit.

Usual disclaimer.....no financial interest yadda yadda yadda, just sharing our experience.
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: r0ssrg on May 29, 2012, 11:35:57 PM
Well I wouldn't have believed it, but the proof is in the pudding. :D
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: noel_w on May 30, 2012, 11:00:14 AM
They don't seem to last long round our place  :angel:
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: BigJules on May 30, 2012, 11:12:28 AM
Someone call MythBusters please.

I wouldn't spend my money on them, but I'd like to see some scientific review before saying they're snake oil (see what I did there  ;D).
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: bullfrog on May 30, 2012, 06:32:41 PM
Winchester made a good one. :cheers:
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: Kalebjarrod on May 30, 2012, 07:09:26 PM
Snakes can feel rodents, if you have rats and mice, snakes for you

Dangerous snakes also love long grass, hawks and kookurburras get them other wise

So what I have found, people who don't like snakes also seem to be more paranoid about them, so they mow, and pickup old timber, sheets of iron, junk etc etc. then they get fewer rodents so they get fewer snakes

Those "snake repellents" work because those people who buy them do all the right things first, then buy one, then congratulate the snake repellent rather than good housekeeping
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: Eureka on May 30, 2012, 07:37:25 PM
I'm with bull frog, two peices of thick walled pipe, sealed with a hinged metal block and some spring loaded  pins to fire the 12 gauge bird shot  shells works fine. Or if you prefer the less home brew version, a shot gun for the timid, a .22  for not so timid.

Personally, walking around making a lot fo noise helps a lot, rarely see the buggers. I dont like Browns, blacks are scary but OK, Dugites are some where in between.
Title: Re: Snake Repellent ... Do they work ?
Post by: noel_w on May 30, 2012, 08:52:12 PM
Quote
Dugites are some where in between.
Hey The Dugites were one of my fav bands of the (early) 80's. IIRC one of their songs was the first one played on 2JJJ when it moved from 2JJ. Mainly because the song was banned from commercial radio. Bit of random OT there sorry.
I thought they were a WA snake